Told through a series of conversations and controversies with a modern day spin on the current unrest of a nation at the cusp of a contentious election, The Tragedy of the Five Fistfuls introduces Readers to Mickey Warrick, or "Key," an enigmatic man-behind-the curtains type of character who will stop at nothing to carry out his sinister agenda, which involves controlling every facet of society, including the very life force that drives each Individual: the human spirit.

After a rogue attempt at bringing down Key with a special artifact from Midnight World, a member of the Five Fistfuls devises a plan of her own, which will hopefully save the human race from its own extinction.